Simple job if you are methodical.
You get a bit of paper and note down what each valve clearance is at the moment. Then you pull all the shims out and record what thickness they are at each valve and write that down under the first row of figures. Now, using the old clearance and the shim thickness you can calculate how much thicker or thinner each shim needs to be for each position. Now you should have a number written down at each valves position saying what thickness it needs to be... except that there is a range or clearances you can have, so you should actually have two figures for each position which will be acceptable, the thickest allowable and the thinnest. Now run through all the shims measuring them and figuring which combination will fit within the allowable range and use the most shims(this cut's down on the number you will have to buy. Once you know what thickness shims you need to buy, go see an engine reconditioner and ask if they will swap your used shims for some of the ones they have sitting on their shelf.